Ukraine continues paying out salary debts through the European court for human rights
Yesterday the European court for human rights pronounced judgments on three cases versus Ukraine unanimously recognizing violation by the country the right for fair trial, the right for free managing one’s property and the absence of efficient national means of protection these rights in Ukraine. Also in one case violation of the right for fair trial because of unreasonable term of trial was recognized.
In these cases Ukrainians Viktor Demchenko (
The European court for human rights indicated in each decision that unfulfillment of court decisions during more than 2-3 years makes the existence of the right for fair trial senseless (clause 6 of the European convention on human rights and fundamental freedoms). At this the government didn’t provide arguments which could justify such duration of unfulfillment of decisions. And since during all this time the claimants couldn’t use their legal property (their money), in two cases the court also recognized violation by the state the right for property of these persons.
The European court for human rights assigned for
In another case by the claim of Mykola Strannikov from Kyiv the European court for human rights also recognized violation by
As long ago as 1995 he brought an action regarding acknowledging him the founder of the private enterprise (Kyiv timber plant) and paying him out compensation from this plant. This case was investigated 8 years and 8 months in courts of 4 levels and was never solved. The European court unanimously recognized this term ‘unreasonable’ in the context of duration of its consideration. He was awarded compensation of 2 thousand euro for the caused damage.
Decisions on these cases will become final unless the government appeals them during some period of time. Though on such cases it happens extremely seldom.
If you find an error on our site, please select the incorrect text and press ctrl-enter.